Advice for a 10 year anniversary trip

Looking for vacation ideas for wife and I for our 10 year anniversary coming up the first week of November. We’re definitely the relaxing type on vacation and enjoy working out and great food/service. I have a lot of Amex and chase points which would be nice to use for the hotel. Was looking at the bora bora st Regis which would cost around 600k points putting us in a reef side villa rather than the overwater bungalow. Would seem like a waste to go all that way and not stay in an OWB. Any other suggestions would be nice. Also, we are coming from La so would prefer destinations that have non stop flights which would likely exclude a Caribbean destination. That’s for the advice!!