Caribbean destination similar to Roatan…

I'm not sure even exactly what we want… BUT I do know I fell in love with the reef snorkeling in Roatan, we stayed in Sandy Bay… and the reef was right out of our back door! I am looking to go back there for our honeymoon, but I was hoping to get some more advice, maybe there are similar places we could checkout? Resort style is fine, airbnb, inclusive or not… all is welcome! (Our budget is about 5 nights and $6000)