Caribbean honeymoon advice

Hey all – we are seeking advice for our honeymoon in August 2025. We're planning on somewhere in the Caribbean. The main things we're looking for:

• Beautiful beaches, relaxing environment and proximity to beaches
• We're looking to stay at a nice hotel or resort, but don't want to spend all of our time there, so looking for places that have nightlife/things to do (bars, live music, restaurants, hiking) but not super touristy
• Easy to get around (ex: rental car)

The places we're considering so far are: Antigua, BVI, St. Lucia, but we're def open to other places!