Caribbean Honeymoon in May 2023

Looking for suggestions or advise on planning a honeymoon this May 2023! We will be flying from Tennessee and are hoping to go somewhere in the Caribbean as it is a little closer to us. Trying to decide between all-inclusive (Sandals) or not, as well as nail down location! We have been looking into Turks and Caicos, Bahamas, St Lucia and St John, but are open to most anything. We are looking at a 7 night span and hoping to keep the budget under $10k.

As far as what we are looking for, we'd certainly like somewhere nice that we can relax at the beach/pool, but hoping for something nearby to more activities, as we will likely get bored after 3-4 days of lounging.

Any recs or advise would be much appreciated!