Honeymoon Options – Caribbean, Virgin Isles

My Fiance and I are looking at honeymoon options for this December. We like the idea of an overwater bungalow with a private pool, but haven’t heard the best things about the resorts in the Caribbean and we don’t want to travel more than 12 hours (NYC area). Whatever we do, we’d like to have butler service and a private plunge pool so we don’t have to leave the property/room much. Please give us your recommendations. Thanks!