Need help choosing foodie honeymoon in Mexico!

Hello, I’ve been poring through old posts trying to find the answer but it seems like there is nothing that quite resolves the struggles we’ve been facing with this decision.

We are big foodies and would like to go to Mexico for our honeymoon (coming from NYC) in early April. Our dream trip would consist of sitting by a beach and having someone bring us a pina colada, or laying on a terrace playing cards.

We are open to either all-inclusive (if the food is AMAZING) or boutique/other, and the only other requirement is that there is some natural beauty to explore/activities to do (scuba/snorkeling, waterfall, salsa dancing class, cooking class, etc.)

I feel like I have exhausted the spreadsheets that are posted in the subs, but any recommendations for under $6000 for 5/6 days would be greatly appreciated!

Again, the focus is on great food (also room service chilaquiles would be a dream) and the ability to do absolutely nothing/a couple of activities.