Need help narrowing down a destination!

My husband and I originally planned to go to England for our honeymoon this upcoming year (waiting a year after our wedding bc I was out of PTO I only get 2 weeks). Well now we are looking into buying a house this next year. Instead of spreading ourselves thin financially or not going at all, we are looking at a different location for our honeymoon instead. Here are some ideas so far:

• Florida Key West
• Hawaii Big Island (been there before and we love it)
• San Diego
• San Francisco
• Arizona

We’re looking somewhere we don’t have to spend $1,200 each on flights (might still be a possibility for CA and HI, we live in MI). Any suggestions? If you’ve been to any of these locations, what do you like, what don’t you like?

Currently I’m leaning towards either the Key West or San Francisco (Nappa Valley, Redwood Forest, the bridge, all of that). My only hesitation for San Fran is that we’re aiming to go in the mid to late fall so it might be too cold.

Any advice helps, thanks!