Struggling with honeymoon decisions!

Hi everyone! My fiance and I are getting married in October, and we want to take our honeymoon directly afterwards, about 6 nights preferably. I'm struggling so hard to decide on what we want to do!! We're leaning towards an all inclusive, preferably in the Caribbean since the flight time isn't as bad, but I think my expectations have been inflated by social media. Our budget is $7500-$9000, and I really would love a room with some kind of water access, like a swim-up or at least a big tub looking outside, but it feels like all of the places within our budget do not have that and look so much more like just a regular hotel! If we're gonna drop thousands on something, I want it to really feel special. I've come to realize overwater villas are extremely far outside of our budget lol, but something in between would be so nice.

We were looking around at St. Lucia, but that especially seems far outside of our budget, even though it's beautiful and I've heard such great things. Does anyone have any recommendations?? Or if you stayed in a more hotel-style all inclusive, did it still feel special and worth the money? Having decision paralysis, especially when preparing to drop that much money on it…