Where to honeymoon ?

Getting married in May of 2026 and coming down to the wire on booking our honeymoon! Bullets of what we are looking for:

• All-inclusive resort is preferred, or at the very least somewhere that has a good amount of food options available
• Traveling out of NYC area, would like to have flight be less than or around 5 or 6 hours (and ideally direct), as this will be our first time out of the country!
• Good quality food is important to us
• We are not partiers, so an AI/resort with parties/DJs/live music doesn't matter
• Budget is about 10k all in for around 8-9 days, including flights. Can go a tad over if it's a perfect situation
• While we want to lay around most of the time, an excursion or 2 would be fun, or potentially sightseeing

At first we were thinking maybe Antigua, since there's direct flights out of JFK, but we are not 100% tied to it. We have also considered Tuscany and staying out by a winery near there. Since we have such little travel experience between the two of us, it's daunting to have so many options! ANY advice, reccos, etc, are welcome!