Advice on cheaper end of Caribbean all inclusives?

We've never stayed at an all inclusive before and it sounds perfect after all this wedding planning. We are kinda tight on budget, hoping to keep it around 2k, including a flight from the north east. We do have access to miles and points, and hoping to use them.

I've looked at waaay to many resorts and companies to keep anything straight. In consideration to some family health issues, we might not be able to go after the wedding, around mid august. I am okay to wait a few weeks or months though, not tied to any particular month. I know hurricane season lasts until Nov, and would prefer to avoid the hurricane zones.

We've been looking at Saint Lucia, Jamaica, and Dominican republic but not picky. Sandals looks tempting, even their cheaper rooms look nice. Quality of room (good bathroom, good bed, AC a must) and food is probably our top priority. We're not club people, and not that athletic either lol. I usually plan big city vacations with a billion things to do, see, and eat – but kinda looking forward to not putting in all that work this time.

Anyone have any must do or must avoids?