Antigua/St. Lucia/Jamaica honeymoon

Does this unicorn exist? Looking to honeymoon for 5-6 nights at an all-inclusive adults-only resort in June 2025 in Antigua, St. Lucia, or Jamaica. Budget is $8k including flights from ATL. Here’s my list of wants: private plunge pool; small, boutique resort; beachfront room if possible; 24/7 room service; butler service. Here’s hubby’s lists of wants: plenty of entertainment in the evenings; plenty of restaurant options; 24/7 room service; TV in the room. Can we meet in the middle? We’ve looked at Keyonna Beach Resort, Coco’s Resort Antigua, Cocobay Antigua, Hammock Cove, Sandals Grande Antigua, Serenity at Coconut Bay, and Excellence Oyster Bay. Haven’t found anything yet that’s in our budget that checks all the boxes and is a good compromise of small/boutique but with also lots of food options and stuff to do in the evenings. Or maybe I’m just scared to pull the trigger and spend $8k on a honeymoon 😅