Caribbean honeymoon in October – need help!

I am getting married in October of this year and my fiancé and I are wanting to book an all inclusive resort for a honeymoon. We were looking at different parts of Mexico, Costa Rica, etc. but have been seeing that this are included under the hurricane season belt so we have been worrying about potential weather.

Do any of y'all have experience with these Caribbean countries that are in the hurricane belt, or have any recommendations for your favorite places outside of this area? We have been looking at other islands like Grenada, Barbados, Aruba, etc. but the resorts we have seen don't really look that great?

Would appreciate any input!