Galley Bay vs Keyonna

Hi everyone, we are looking at honeymooning in the Caribbean June 2025 for 7 nights. We want an adults only all inclusive with a nice beach and private pool, but don’t want to go to Mexico/Jamaica/DR. So far, we have mainly focused on Antigua due to price point and variety but are open to other options. Price point around $7k but willing to go higher if we believe it’s really worth it.

So far we are mainly looking at Galley Bay and Keyonna in Antigua. Keyonna would be the beachfront cottage with a private pool and galley bay would be the private cottage with pool. We want to do water activities as well and understand that galley bay is better for this. We have also looked at hammock cove but aren’t sure if the premium is worth it yet ($9.3k for a non refundable room).

Does anyone have feedback/has been to both and is able to speak to the pros and cons and overall recommendation? Also would love recommendations for other resorts on other islands if our description matches anything!

Thanks!