My Fiancé and I have been going back and forth from one island/resort to another trying to figure out the best location for a Honeymoon for 5 days in April 2023. It doesn't need to be all-inclusive but that all we've really found. We've gone from Sandals St Lucia to Jade Mountain (axed due to lack of 4th wall), to Excellence Punta Cana, to other Sandals to Park Hyatt St. Kitts (booked for our dates) and currently sitting on Excellence Oyster Bay in Jamaica. Cost isn't much of an issue but obviously the best deal helps.
Currently we are liking the Excellence resorts since they appear to be so much cheaper than Sandals for what seems to be the same offerings. The list of things we are mainly wanting is probably what everyone else wants, good food, beaches and spas along a private plunge pool (preferred) or swim-up suite.