Help us pick a location!

My fiance and I love to travel and we very rarely have disagreements. The one thing we're not totally aligned about is where to travel for our honeymoon!

For me: I'd love to go somewhere beachy, extravagant and cultural. I would love to go to museums, try many different restaurants and bars, and talk to locals. Think Amalfi Coast, South of France, Greek Islands.

For him: He would like to do something like St. Lucia, Maldives, etc. — Somewhere obscenely gorgeous and we can be catered to for our every whim.

Is there a destination that meets both of these desires?! We're in the very early planning stages and we're willing to spend on the ultimate honeymoon experience.

Thanks in advance!