Honeymoon in Italy .. Suggestions please! :)

Hi everyone!

So as a very gracious present, my fiance's sister and brother in law are offering to pay for a group trip to Italy for our honeymoon!! We're so grateful, because we really aren't in a position to do that ourselves. But my question is …

What would you recommend, doing a Milan/Venice/Verona/Lake Como trip, or a Rome/Vatican/Amalfi Coast trip?? They want us to have an idea by this weekend.

Some background: I went to Italy before on a school trip, and we ended up doing the Venice/Florence/Rome trip. So I really feel like no matter what we do, this is an absolute win!! Just wondering if any fellow wedding planners had some ideas? Thanks 🙂