Honeymoon in Italy

For people who are familiar with Italy, my Fiance and I are planning our honeymoon there probably for about 12 days starting on October 25th. The top places we want to go are Amalfi, Capri, Florence, Tuscany, and Rome.

Since it's our honeymoon we really don't want to be rushed and we want to relax and do things at a leisurely pace, but we also want to get a good amount of sightseeing and history in there! 🙂

So my question is, where would you recommend we go first and what order should we do all of this? I read online it can be rainy on the Amalfi coast in early November so I was thinking maybe we should go to Amalfi first and maybe Rome last?

Any advice is greatly appreciated! Thank you! 🙂