How do I start planning my European honeymoon?

My husband and I are very overwhelmed with all the options being thrown at us when it comes to traveling to Europe. We are planning on staying in an alpine village near the Italian Alps but can’t nail down which one to choose. We would love to have multiple meal options and maybe a pub nearby. The next portion of the stay is where we are clueless. Can’t decide between the Amalfi Coast or Greece. The Amalfi Coast seems amazing but I would love something very laid back. Please give us GUIDANCE 😭