Is butler service worth it?

My fiancé and I are planning a week long honeymoon somewhere in the Caribbean and are trying to decide if the butler level is worth it. This will be our first time out of the country, our first vacation together, and the first time either of us have really been at an all inclusive resort so we want to make sure our honeymoon feels extra special! The Sandals resorts have so many amazing club level rooms that check our other boxes, but the butler suites would still be within budget.

Any advice??