Late August Honeymoon Caribbean

Late August 2022 Fly out of Indianapolis Want all inclusive (but not drinkers) Budget around $10k

Looking for somewhere quiet with a nice private room (preferably separate structure) and pool/spa. Don't need a ton of activities. Want good food and safe environment.

Concerned about potential hurricane or rainy season. Have looked at Sandals, surprised how many of the nice rooms are already booked.

Thanks!