No idea where to go!

Hey, everyone!

As mentioned in the title, my fiancée and I are getting married in November, and we have no clue where to go or what to look for. I think the issue is my very-specific list. I've never been on a trip like this, and I don't even know where to begin.

The aforementioned list:

1. Tropical- Want to be on the beach, drinking mai-tais, and hanging around the hotel pool

2. Budget-ish- Including the flights (flying out of Cincinnati) and any food and drinks, I'd like to spend 2500, MAYBE 3000.

3. Some things to do- Would like a place where we can do a couple of activities, but plan on spending most of the time at the beach. Think 1-2 activities (zip-line, museum, putt-putt,etc), but would like a few restaurants/clubs to go to.

4. 5 nights- Check in Sunday, leave Friday morning.

I think an all-inclusive resort with a drinks package is the best thing, but I don't really know where to start there either.

Any help would be appreciated! Thank you!