Philippines or Caribbean

My fiance and I are planning our honeymoon for mid/end February 2026. I was set on the phillipines due to the beautiful beaches and islands, but now I keep reading negative reviews and experiences from the hassle of flights, food quality, and dirty cities. My plan was to stay in Shangrila boracay for 4 nights, and in Pangalusian in El Nido for 5 nights with island hopping tours. But now I’m not sure if doing a Caribbean all inclusive would be a better experience. For reference, we’re in our late 20s, living in Florida, USA. We’re seeking relaxing, beautiful views/beach, and great service. I was pushing for the long flight of a trip since we can travel to the Caribbean easily at any other point of our lives. But not sure if it’s worth it? We’ve already been to Thailand, Australia, and New Zealand. Appreciate any advice, thanks!