Planning an affordable Caribbean honeymoon (November)

Hello, Reddit!

My fiancee and I are getting married in mid-November, but we’ve yet to decide what we want to do for our honeymoon. We definitely want to go somewhere warm, beachy, pooly, all-inclusive, and drinky. We’re also young (in our 20s), so we don’t have a ton of money – we were hoping to do $3500 or less. A friend told me about cheapcarribean.com , and it seems like you can get some good deals here, but I don’t really know what I’m looking for. Is there anywhere that is ruled out weather-wise in November? Is there some way to get a great deal? Is the “travel protection” on these websites a scam?

Thanks in advance!