Rosewood Little Dix Bay vs. Cap Juluca

I’ve narrowed our honeymoon options for October 2026 for 7 nights to two resorts – Rosewood Little Dix Bay (LDB) and Cap Juluca (CJ). I know it’s peak hurricane season, but we’re hoping to head out right after the wedding and willing to take the gamble. Both resorts are coming in at a similar nightly rate (Ocean View Junior Suite at LDB vs. Deluxe Beachfront Rooms at CJ). It seems they offer different vibes that we both like: LDB seems to have more activities and a bit more tropical feel (beach drops, on-site experiences), while CJ feels more low-key and exclusive. Pools seem meh at both, but we'll be on loungers on the beach mostly. We’re ultimately looking for a relaxing beachfront stay with great food and drinks, and some light exploring, so I’d love to hear any thoughts or personal experiences with either resort.