Secluded beach honeymoon spot in Americas

Hi all,

I am looking for a weeklong honeymoon spot somewhere in Central America or the Caribbean / Islands. We are looking to go in November.

I am looking for somewhere as secluded as possible on the beach (with a nice sand beach). All we want to do is sit on the beach, swim in the ocean, maybe do some snorkeling, eat good food, and relax.

We want to avoid large crowds and big touristy spots (though this might not be an issue in November). We don’t need any additional amenities and don’t need a super big fancy resort.

I don’t have a strict budget, but I have been finding some places for a few hundred a night in the Dominican and Costa Rica, and that is looking like the right price.

Any suggestions? Thanks!