Totally unsure of where to go!!!

Getting married this upcoming September and she gave me the job of finding a place to honeymoon in January 2023. We both agreed we don’t want to go somewhere either of us have gone before. We both would love to just relax on a beach all inclusive if possible. I’m not 100% sure on budget yet but really just looking for ideas as of right now. Between the 2 of us we’ve been to the Bahamas, St. Thomas, Italy, Greece, Aruba, Puerto Rico, Dominican Republic, Cancun, and Hawaii. We’d be leaving from NYC. Would prefer a flight less than 8 hours or so. My brother who is an avid traveler mentioned the Azores Islands but I haven’t researched much. Appreciate any help or insight!