Aruba or Jamaica for July Honeymoon.

Hi Everyone

Me and my fiancé are looking to have our honeymoon in late July (our wedding is in April) because both of our birthdays are towards the end of July and we would love to have an extended trip/honeymoon during that time.
Right now we are trying to decide between Aruba and Jamaica and hoping to get some feedback on people that have been there or have some insight into what either are like. Some things about us:

1. We typically prefer all inclusive to not worry about budgeting.

2. We want to do some off resort exploration/activities as we did not our last vacation.

3. Has some night life/ dancing activities.

Any info, recommendations or help would be appreciated. 😊