November Honeymoon in the Caribbean

My fiancee and I are making it official November 10 2018 and going on our honeymoon the week after. We are looking to go somewhere Caribbean where we have not been previously and looking for advice.

We are pretty laid back (not very adventurous) so will most likely go the all-inclusive resort route. More about the relaxation, celebrating and pampering each other, and taking in the sun/beautiful views/beaches/adult beverages.

With that said, where should we go? The main places we have been looking into: St Lucia, Nevis, Turks & Caicos, Jamaica, and British Virgin Isles